Tighter Basic Compliance Assessment (BCA) thresholds and rising visa refusals are not a covert tactic to keep international student numbers under control, delegates at the international student recruitment conference hosted by Universities UK International (UUKi) heard this morning.
“There is no cap on the number of students that we want to see coming to the UK, but very much a focus on genuine students,” said Oliver Rae, head of work, study, family and Ukraine services at the Home Office.
Instead, he said that changes to the BCA system were in response to an increase in people coming to the UK on a student visa and then claiming asylum rather than engaging with their studies, as well as the fact that the thresholds had not been revised since they were first introduced in 2015.
Rae observed that the Home Office had become more vigilant towards “post-Covid abuse” of the immigration system. Demand for studying in the UK surged to record highs in the years following the pandemic, which at the time was attributed to pent-up demand after years of global lock downs.
“There was significant concern, not just in terms of the swift increase in volume of students at that time, but the associated risks that came with the increase in volume,” said Rae.
The UK government is clamping down on the misuse of the asylum system, with four countries – Afghanistan, Cameroon, Myanmar and Sudan – currently subject to a total brake on study visa issuance. The government has said it introduced the controversial policy following a noticeable trend in student asylum claims from these nationalities.
Analysis published in The PIE News suggests that other, larger markets offer a similar asylum risk profile but are not yet subject to study visa bans.
While many UK institutions have complained of a surge in visa refusals – particularly for the January 2026 intake – Rae said that the overall refusal rate for the Summer 2026 intake was around 4%.
However, he pointed out that there were some markets that were noticeably higher risk. For example, he said that “we were we were getting close to around a 20% refusal rate of Pakistan in the summer period”.
“Over the last couple of years, we’ve become much more mature to where risk exists, the type of markets and the type of individuals that are targeting the immigration system,” Rae said. “So I think it’s fair to say that, generally speaking, our winter cohort is generally of higher risk than the summer cohort.”
Alex Lock, head of immigration compliance at Anglia Ruskin University, said that markets the institution was recruiting from that had very low visa refusal rates last year had “gone toxic for us very, very quickly”. Snap changes such as these made it important for universities to keep track of and act quickly on real-time data, he said.
Over the last couple of years, we’ve become much more mature to where risk exists, the type of markets and the type of individuals that are targeting the immigration system
Oliver Rae, UK Home Office
“During the summer surge… the only way we knew there was a problem in Nigeria was when we were monitoring our data in real time,” he said.
“What we’re now seeing centrally is universities like ours who have always been under that 4% metric now having a higher refusal percentage and not really knowing what next we can do, having to step in and withdraw from markets,” Lock warned.
Rebecca Sandford, international student policy lead at the Department for Education, stressed that international students remain important to the UK government and she acknowledged that institutions are trying to strike the right balance between compliance and caution “in what is really challenging the landscape at the moment”.
“We know that the BCA changes are significant, and it’s something that we discuss quite regularly with colleagues at UUKi,” she said.
“Our position is that if institutions have better and more timely information about compliance risk, there is greater scope to manage those risks intelligently, rather than simply retreating from particular markets,” she added.
“If we want institutions to recruit internationally with confidence, including across a diverse range of markets and equities, they need to be able to understand how to manage risks effectively.”
UK university stakeholders have also indicated their frustration with what they perceive as an unfair, opaque UKVI interview system that unfairly targets certain students. Sources speaking to The PIE have told stories of students being refused a visa because they did not know minute details of their chosen institution, such as how many trees are on campus or where the nearest bus stop was.
But Rae said that UKVI has interviewed noticeably fewer prospective students this year for the Summer intake. “That’s as a result of being able to gear caseworkers up to looking at risk in more detail and looking at specifics rather than taking a more broad brush approach,” he said.
However, Rae acknowledged that the Home Office could have done more to articulate some of the reasons outside of refusal rates that certain markets are seen as high risk by UKVI. “One of the metrics that isn’t quite clear is some of the data that you provide back to us post student arrivals,” he said, referencing international student completion rates.
However, “there’s an acknowledgement that we we don’t always get the decisions right”, he added.
Lock posited that universities would have a greater chance of quickly responding to perceived compliance risks in certain markets if the Home Office shared this information more transparently. “If that was shared with us, we could join you,” he pointed out.
Sophie Turnbull, director of international student recruitment at UWE Bristol, highlighted the “human impact” of visa refusals on prospective international students, saying this was what “keeps me up at night”.
“It’s no longer [just] these refusals… it’s the stories that sit behind them,” she said.





