“It is simply bizarre that fly-by-night business schools should be treated in the same way as Imperial College,” said Policy Exchange director of research Iain Mansfield at UUKi’s International Student Recruitment Conference this week.
“I believe it was Benjamin Franklin who said, “‘If we do not hang together, we will all hang separately,'” he told delegates. “I would suggest the reverse is true for the university sector.”
“Rather, the decision to hang together has been the policy of the sector of the UK in general, and it has resulted in you all being hung together by the Home Office,” Mansfield added, making a broader point around a perceived imbalance in standards between different institutions that are able to issue international students visas.
It comes amid a wider conversation about compliance, as new rules tighten Basic Compliance Assessment (BCA) requirements even as visa refusals soar.
Yesterday, The PIE News revealed that almost eight in 10 students invited to a credibility interview with UKVI will be refused a visa.
Speaking earlier at the conference, Oliver Rae stressed that the Home Office is not tightening compliance as an indirect way of capping international student numbers. Rather, UKVI case workers have become better at spotting potential risk indicators that certain students are not seeking to study in the UK for genuine reasons.
Mansfield also signalled concerns over the Graduate Route, which the UK government has recently revealed it will extend to two years for highly compliant insitutitions.
He blasted it as a “backdoor to long-term migration”.
There was a real concern that we are just simply selling visas for 12,000 pounds a head. If we wanted to do that, the government itself would directly cut out the middleman
Iain Mansfield, Policy Exchange
Mansfield also suggested that such students would be less likely to attend institutions with higher fees for international students, estimating that most would be paying between £12,000 and £14,000 for their program.
“There was a real concern that we are just simply selling visas for £12,000 a head. If we wanted to do that, the government itself would directly cut out the middleman,” he said.
Mansfield acknowledged that there are genuine students looking to study in the UK “who we might want to attract”. “But this is a concern here, and it’s part of the one-size-fits-all approach to the sector,” he warned.
He waved away a common defence of international students’ place in the UK’s overall immigration landscape – the “assumption that students come and then leave” – saying that this “is simply not the case” due to the Graduate Route, which currently allows international graduates to stay in the UK for two years after they finish their studies.
“Like or not, means the student migration can’t be considered separately to the local migration phase,” he said.
Going forward, Mansfield urged the UK’s higher education institutions to avoid “needless provocations” of the government and general public.
“It genuinely baffles me to understand why [in] a sector seeking to win hearts and minds on this issue, several dozen universities have chosen to signal their contempt for immigration law by declaring themselves universities of sanctuary, a term generally associated with the US with non-compliance with national standards of immigration law,” he said.
Similarly, Mansfield said he struggled to understand why the UK’s cash-strapped universities would prioritise offering scholarships to Gazan students affected by the ongoing conflict.
“I think these decisions are made in isolation without thinking about the overall signal they send about where the sector stands,” he said.







