Sign up

Have some pie!

Trump visa suspensions could cost US economy $223 million

The suspension of H-1B, H-2B, L and some J non-immigrant visa categories could cost the US economy more than $223 million. Photo: Unsplash

75% of cultural exchange participants developed a more positive opinion of the US

In a letter to the administration signed by over 800 businesses and organisations, the AIE said the move will “very likely lead to an increase in layoffs among program sponsors and their host partners in the US, which will have a negative ripple effect throughout [the] economy”.

“The presidential proclamation will cost, not save, American jobs”

“In addition, host families may be unable to return to work without necessary childcare,” it added.

“In effect, the presidential proclamation will cost, not save, American jobs.”

Deniz Akar, managing director of Turkey-based Global Visions, had 1,000 students signed up to take part in work and travel programs in the US in 2020.

So far, only 100 have gone – those who had visas before the Covid-19 outbreak – and most are choosing to wait until next year.

“If [the ban] was because of Covid-19 students could understand, but to ban cultural exchange programs because of jobs doesn’t make sense. They aren’t taking jobs from US people,” Akar told The PIE News.

“A big concern among students and agents is that it’s going to be extended. For the US, these programs are very important for cultural exchange. If they extend it they are going to lose their reputation around the world with young people.”

In Trump’s proclamation restricting the visas until the end of this year, he cited unemployment and the impact that non-immigrant workers would have on the availability of jobs for US citizens, adding that “temporary workers are often accompanied by their spouses and children, many of whom also compete against American workers”.

However, many organisations involved in cultural exchange programs such as au pairing and summer camps question why they have been included in this considering their participants are usually university-educated youth staying in the US short-term without dependants.

“A vast majority of Exchange Visitor Program participants cite cultural exchange as the primary factor for taking part in the program,” noted AIE.

“75%of cultural exchange participants, on average, developed a more positive opinion of the US after their program experience.”

The immediate impact of the ruling may be limited – with embassies and visa centres still shut and travel restrictions in place participants couldn’t have done their programs anyway – but stakeholders told The PIE they worry that the country’s reputation among young people overseas will needlessly suffer.

“A big concern among students and agents is that it’s going to be extended”

Akar noted that studying in countries like Canada and Ireland, where studying comes with work rights, are becoming popular options for students.

Au Pair in America , which is now unable to hire overseas au pairs, has started an online campaign to “save J1 visas”.

“We remain hopeful that if the order is modified or when the order expires, embassies around the world will have fully reopened and other travel restrictions will have lifted and program operations can resume quickly,” Au Pair in America said in a statement.

Language schools and bilingual education programs may also be hit with staff shortages. Local media in Utah, where public schools run around 200 dual language immersion programs, noted that each year the state hires 60-70 native-speaking teachers from countries like China, Brazil, Germany and Peru to staff these programs on J1 visas.

“This doesn’t directly affect us since most students will enter on F1 visas but the noise around the potential suspension of OPT is unsettling especially when viewed against a wider global policy context,” noted Tim O’Brien, SVP new partner development and INTO University Partnerships.

“Canada and the UK both confirmed post-study work privileges for students who begin their programs online, and there was an announcement from the UK government on three year post-study work visas for STEM PhD students.”

Whether OPT will be impacted in future legislation is unclear, although the AIE told The PIE that they had “heard reports that the administration may curtail Optional Practical Training through the regulatory process”.

As of July 6, the US has ruled that wholly-online study from September will not be permissible for international students, in new SEVP guidance that has caused shock and consternation in the sector.

Related articles

Still looking? Find by category:

Add your comment

One Response to Trump visa suspensions could cost US economy $223 million

  1. Employers have a long history of predicting doom when their supply of cheap immigrants is threatened. Consider:
    “The crop of the present year, although deemed a short one, taxed the labor capacity of the state to the utmost. If such was the situation this year, what will it be when the numerous young orchards now just coming into bearing will be producing full crops? The labor is not now in the country to handle such an increase in production.”
    That was written in 1883 against the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882. Fruit farmers in California claimed crops would rot in the fields if more Asians were not brought in for the harvest. The rotting didn’t happen.
    Then there was the great tomato scare of the early 1960s.The head of the California Agriculture Department told Congress to expect a 50% drop in tomato production if the Bracero guest-worker program got the ax. That drop didn’t happen. Instead, tomato farmers were forced to mechanize. Output rose and prices fell from $30 a ton in 1960 to $22 a ton in 1970. In 1960, California farmers paid 45,000 workers to pick 2.2 million tons of tomatoes. In 1996, just 5,500 workers picked 12 million tons. Tomato acreage grew from 130,000 acres in 1960 to 360,00 acres in 1996. Tomato consumption rose from 44 pounds per person in 1960 to 75 pounds in 1994.

    Not only has restricted immigration historically not produced gloom and doom but rather prosperity. Immigration is federal government manipulation of the market place by artificially inflating the supply of labor driving down wages. Time and time again we have seen the market self correct any shortage of skilled labor.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Disclaimer: All user contributions posted on this site are those of the user ONLY and NOT those of The PIE Ltd or its associated trademarks, websites and services. The PIE Ltd does not necessarily endorse, support, sanction, encourage, verify or agree with any comments, opinions or statements or other content provided by users.

To receive The PIE Weekly with our top stories and insights, and other updates from us, please