Sign up

Have some pie!

TOEIC scandal students call for “transparent scheme” to clear names

International students accused of cheating on TOEIC tests in 2014 have protested outside the UK Parliament, while 200 have signed a letter to prime minister Boris Johnson calling for a “free and transparent scheme” that will review their cases and clear their names.

TOEICOnly a few students were able to attend the protest due to Covid-19 restrictions. Photo: Migrant Voice

200 students signed the letter

In 2014, a documentary filmed by the BBC’s Panorama exposed a group rigging TOEIC exams, which are used to prove language abilities for immigration to the UK.

“This is a case that the Home Office has got very, very badly wrong. And they need to put it right”

A subsequent investigation by ETS, who administer TOEIC, revealed thousands more cases of alleged cheating that resulted in the Home Office revoking the visas of almost 34,000 students.

“It had since become clear that many of those students, almost certainly most of them, were entirely innocent and they’ve been left in limbo for the last six years, not able to study, not able to work,” Stephen Timms, the MP who presented the letter to the prime minister on behalf of the students, told The PIE News.

“It’s a disgrace. Exactly like the Windrush scandal, this is a case that the Home Office has got very, very badly wrong. And they need to put it right.”

While many of the students who wished to attend the protest were unable to do so due to Covid-19 rules, those that did spoke about how being accused of cheating on the exams and the resulting fallout has caused serious physical and mental health issues, bankruptcy, separation of families, and taken away six years of their lives.

“I was always a good student. I did my chemistry bachelor’s back home and I finished my master’s in the UK. I have my IELTS score. I have my Pearson’s [PTE] score,” said one of the students involved, Shana Shaikh.

“It’s like I have done a huge crime in this country without being proven guilty or without any chance to prove that I am innocent,” she continued.

“My future is gone because this is the age where people are settling down. But I’m still struggling to prove myself innocent for a thing which I have never done and would never do because I have a sufficient knowledge of the language.”

Some students describe not knowing that there was an issue with their TOEIC results until years later.

Another student, Nomi Raja was unaware he had been caught up in the scandal until immigration officers arrived at his house one morning in 2015.

“They banged on my door. They asked for my ID and then they said ‘we need to take you with us’,” he recalled.

“I asked what I had done, but they refused to answer. And they said we need to take you for a few days and then later we’ll see what we’re going to do. I was in detention for 125 days.”

In February 2019 – almost five years later – he was finally granted in-country right of appeal.

“I won my case after five and a half years and it cost me over £30,000 in legal costs to get all my rights back for a crime which I never committed,” he said.

The students have received backing from several MPs, including Stephen Timms, the charity Migrant Voice and education groups.

The National Union of Students’ president Larissa Kennedy told The PIE that the NUS “fully support” the students.

“It’s good to see that the Home Office has made a few concessions on this matter this year, in response to pressure from ourselves and legal firms,” said Migrant Voice director, Nazek Ramadan.

“I won my case after five and a half years and it cost me over £30,000 in legal costs”

“We very much hope that these are just the prelude to a genuine solution, laid out in the letter from the students, that can finally put an end to this injustice.”

The students too are hopeful that their latest efforts will lead to concrete action on the part of the government.

I profoundly believe that the prime minister will keep his promise to listen and put things right,” said student Sheikh Shariful Amin.

A Home Office spokesperson told The PIE that courts have “consistently found that the evidence the Home Office had at the time was sufficient to take action”.

A report last year accused the Home Office being “quick to act on imperfect evidence, but slow in responding to indications that innocent people may have been caught up in its actions” and accepting evidence presented by ETS “at face value” while not accepting evidence from those students accused of cheating.

At the time of publication, ETS had not responded to requests for comment.

Related articles

Still looking? Find by category:

Add your comment

2 Responses to TOEIC scandal students call for “transparent scheme” to clear names

  1. I am also victim of this cruel policy of home office on toeic, I had been clear my name and won from court last year then I have been given two months visa to again continue my studies after 5 years then I have applied in ten different universities of UK but unfortunately My enrolment application was rejected by universities on these grounds coz of long education gap and no progression in academic career and immigration history etc then I made an application on dissertation leave then I have got appeal right now it’s been 8 months waiting for my appeal to be heard in court, In this all period of six years I have spent more than £20 000 thousand on my case separation of family mental health issue my driving’ licence was revoked and bank account was frozen and taken away six years of my life

  2. I was a victim as well. I have done my undergraduate from university of Sunderland and then applied for my MS. I have been rejected and forced to come back to my home country. I didn’t even submitted my Toeic while applied for my MS, however I have been accused as I participated Toeic once in 2013. Now I am afraid to apply to UK or any other country. I haven’t had any appeal right to prove my self innocent. It was highly frustrating and totally unfair. We want justice.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Disclaimer: All user contributions posted on this site are those of the user ONLY and NOT those of The PIE Ltd or its associated trademarks, websites and services. The PIE Ltd does not necessarily endorse, support, sanction, encourage, verify or agree with any comments, opinions or statements or other content provided by users.
PIENEWS

Download The PIEoneer Awards White Paper for deep dive insights into this year’s highly commended finalists and winners, and watch videos showcasing all our finalists’ entries.

Download Now