Sign up

Have some pie!

Australia: internationals working as cleaners “exploited”

Overseas students who work as cleaners in Australian shopping centres are being exploited by their employers while retailers enjoy major profit rises, a new study has claimed. The report, by Victorian TAFE International and the union United Voice, highlights extreme workloads, underpayment and a culture of discrimination as problems, and says internationals are less likely to complain than the rest of the workforce.

"Unsure of their rights many international students can be easily exploited"

“Both government and shopping centre owners could be considered to be in breach of their duty of care to international students by failing to educate them on their rights, and allowing exploitation to flourish,” the report states.

The report, which estimates some 50% of cleaners are overseas students, surveyed 391 “retail cleaners” in Victoria, 41 of whom were international students.

“A number had not received all the pay they were owed while more than half struggled to survive on their wages”

It found that one in three of the latter group had suffered stress about their workloads and over a third worked additional hours without pay.

A number had not received all the pay they were owed while more than half struggled to survive on their wages, which averaged the legal minimum – around AUS$17 an hour – but could be lower.

“You talk about rights, they give you more job, they give you more punishment, they give you mental pressure,” says one South Asian student interviewed for the report.

While Australian cleaners also faced these problems, some issues were specific to overseas students. Nearly 40 per cent reported that their supervisors were sometimes rude or abusive – significantly higher than their Australian colleagues at 20.6 per cent.

Some had also experienced discrimination based on their race, particularly Indians who made up around 50 per cent of the cleaners interviewed. Moreover, 25% were wary of approaching a union compared to 14% of domestic cleaners. “Unsure of their rights…many international students can be easily exploited,” warns the report.

The report blames the generally poor conditions on a “highly competitive” retail cleaning industry where providers cut labour costs to win contracts, and it said retailers were doing little to change things. While Westfield, one of Australia’s leading shopping centre chains reported a 31.4% profit increase to AUS$800 million in the first half of 2012, some contractors were shown to underpay by as much as $139 per week.

“These issues keep coming up, that’s what concerns me”

A spokesman for the Shopping Centre Council of Australia said United Voice, one of Australia’s largest trade unions, said the survey was a “stunt” to win higher pay for its members. However Australia’s race discrimination commissioner, Dr Helen Soze, called on the Council to act.

“These issues keep coming up, that’s what concerns me,” she told ABC Radio.

“[Shopping centres] need to be auditing their own practices, they need to be checking on what’s happening with their contractors. They need to be sure that they are compliant with their legal obligations in terms of they’re bringing those contractors into play.”

Last month the Australian Human Rights Commission introduced a set of principles to protect the rights of international students, following a number of high profile cases of abuse across Australia, including attacks on Indian students in 2010 and widespread exploitation by landlords.

Related articles

Still looking? Find by category:

Add your comment

5 Responses to Australia: internationals working as cleaners “exploited”

  1. Hello
    This is very true. I have seen this happen many time ans pity the students as they are very afraid to complain. I think we should name and shame such companies.

  2. Unfortunately they gain very little sympathy with present socio political climate in Australia due to concerted and strategic campaigns by the “anti immigration” lobby in mainstream (and even education) media which claims they are taking jobs from young Australians (even if young Australians are not interested and/or unemployable).

    One example here from University News whose Australian “journalist” Geoff Maslen reporting research from one of Australia’s most infamous “anti immigration” “anti population growth” “anti international student” etc. “researchers” Dr. Bob Birrell of Monash University:

    http://www.universityworldnews.com/article.php?story=20121121083314779

    Curiously there is a deafening silence from the Australian international education sector of what many view as a neo “white Australia policy” with visa and immigration changes introduced in recent years?

    http://aiecquest.wordpress.com/2012/11/26/negative-impact-of-international-students/

    http://aiecquest.wordpress.com/2012/11/16/australian-population-growth-myths/

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Disclaimer: All user contributions posted on this site are those of the user ONLY and NOT those of The PIE Ltd or its associated trademarks, websites and services. The PIE Ltd does not necessarily endorse, support, sanction, encourage, verify or agree with any comments, opinions or statements or other content provided by users.
PIENEWS

To receive The PIE Weekly with our top stories and insights, and other updates from us, please

SIGN UP HERE