Sign up

Have some pie!

Australia: stranded students having “thoughts of self-harm”

The report found that students are suffering from depression, anxiety and thoughts of self-harm. Photo: Pexels

"Nearly half of the students reported that they were negatively affected by their rental situation"

The CISA Stranded Students Survey Preliminary Report also found that students are facing serious financial challenges – paying bills and storage for belongings in Australia despite not being able to access those services. 

“A highly concerning 30% of students have had thoughts of self-harm”

Now stakeholders have warned that students may be attracted to other study destinations such as Canada and the UK which also offer post-study work rights. 

“Approximately 160,000 international students enrolled in an Australian institution are currently outside the country (DESE, 2021), most of which have been stranded offshore since the implementation of Australia’s border closure in March 2020,” CISA said in the report.  

“As the peak national body representing international students in [the] tertiary sector in Australia, CISA has been advocating for a national coordinated plan for international students’ return since the start of the pandemic.” 

The survey was initiated on March 23, 2021 and within two weeks had received 107 responses from individual students.

Nearly half of the respondents (47%) were students who have not travelled to Australia, and over one-third (35%) were students who departed Australia during university holiday in 2019-20 who were then caught in limbo during the border closure.

Source: CISA

“The picture painted on [the] mental health impact was shockingly distressing. A whopping nine out of ten students reported to [have] experienced stress regarding their situation,” the report said. 

Some 74% of students reported self-diagnosed anxiety and 71% reported self-diagnosed depression. 

“A highly concerning 30% of students have had thoughts of self-harm and one-fourth reported to exhibit clinically diagnosed anxiety or depression,” the report added. 

Additional feedback from students included reports of mental trauma caused by prolonged uncertainty, losing motivation from purely theoretical teaching in degrees such as medicine and feelings of regrets and that their careers have been ruined. 

It does take a really big toll on mental health”

Students also reported being pressured to get married due to cultural reasons and give up their studies, marriage breakdown due to distance and stress, and shame and humiliation by family and friends.

It does take a really big toll on mental health,” Mahitha Varikoti, a student of Central Queensland University, Melbourne, told The PIE News. 

“I have a breakdown every two days or three days when I realise that I don’t have opportunities, when I realise that my visa is going to expire. 

“I realise that friends of my age who are back in India, have actually travelled back to other countries and I’m still sitting here and listening to classes online. Given the time difference and the kind of exposure that I wanted, this is something that I would not prefer,” she added. 

The majority of respondents to the report said they were experiencing financial impact, with the biggest cause being paying bills (43%) and storage for belongings (39%) without making use of the services. 

Nearly half of the students reported that they were negatively affected by their rental situation, with 30% continuing to pay for rent even though they were not in the country. 

Some 18% had to pay a penalty as they were forced to break their lease. Over one-third of students reported that they had taken an income hit as they lost their part-time or casual job in Australia – 8% of students said they had lost their full-time job.

Source: CISA

All of my things and belongings are in Australia. I’m paying rent over there. For the first few months I paid the full amount,” Varikoti told The PIE. 

“Then later, when my landlord realised my situation, he did reduce the rent. But still I am paying so that my things are not thrown out of the house or I’m not evicted. I’ve been patiently waiting from March 2020. I was under the impression that in July they were going to open. Then I thought it would be in October or November.

This is the time when Australia literally was not showing any cases, or at least not as many cases. So there comes a saturation point where you don’t believe anymore and the government is not answering any questions that students have. They do not have any medium of communication. They do not answer. They do not give out information,” she added. 

CISA’s report showed that over half of the respondents (55%) noted that they’re waiting to come back onshore to complete their courses. Some 43% of students have considered going to a different country to study. 

Source: CISA

“We know that the frustration of students stranded offshore is growing – Australia started accepting visa applications in July last year with the promise that if you had a visa, offshore/online study would count towards post-study work rights,” Robert Parsonson, executive officer of ISEAA, told The PIE. 

“Of course, this means nothing if they cannot get into the country to study. The Australian immigration department has still not clarified the ratio of offshore vs onshore study needed to qualify for the PSWR. 

“Canada and the UK are now offering good PSWR conditions and are attracting students to switch from Australia. In particular, the UK has a one-year post-graduate study masters with PSWR opportunities that is very attractive to the Indian market,” he added.  

Ravi Lochan Singh, president of the Association of Australian Education Representatives in India told The PIE that the education sector has realised that the Australian government is unlikely to welcome new international students in 2021. 

“There might be some returns of the stranded students but prospective students have certainly opened up to consider other education destinations that are open and accepting travellers such as Canada and UK,” he said. 

Lochan Singh did note that nothing is certain due to the unpredictable nature of the pandemic.

“India is currently experiencing an aggressive second wave of the infections and most cities are entering a phase of lockdowns. School leaving and university exams have been deferred. These exams typically are held in March-April and it is our expectation that they might only be held in July or August in this year. 

“If this happens, then there will be Indian students who will not be able to commence even in UK or Canada even if these countries are open to visas and travel. This is a real possibility,” he added.

Related articles

Still looking? Find by category:

Add your comment

4 Responses to Australia: stranded students having “thoughts of self-harm”

  1. They should not have given students false hopes. Irony is, they are giving out student visas even now though borders are closed for over a year now. Aussie government has lost all its shame and morals.

  2. No one knew when borders will open. (I think India’s situation now shows how little anyone can predict this virus.)

    Yes, Australia is still issuing visas, but the minister has said that 2022 looks like the earliest date. Visa extensions are free.

    It is a terrible situation, but it is the worst pandemic the world has seen and we see how other countries have tried to ‘manage’ the pandemic. If anyone knew we would be closed for so long, no visas would have been issued. The money is not much for any country.

  3. Australia must atleast allow vaccinated students to return back and commence their studies. The students who came back to India should be the first one to return.

  4. since when do students become stranded in their own country, and the consistent theme that students will go elsewhere if the australia government doesn’t do the unthinkable and allow students entry now. my advice is if you think your education is more important than the health of australian citizens, please go to the UK or Canada.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Disclaimer: All user contributions posted on this site are those of the user ONLY and NOT those of The PIE Ltd or its associated trademarks, websites and services. The PIE Ltd does not necessarily endorse, support, sanction, encourage, verify or agree with any comments, opinions or statements or other content provided by users.

To receive The PIE Weekly with our top stories and insights, and other updates from us, please